3 reasons why Amorim’s Man United are worse than Ten Hag’s United

Manchester United’s recent performances under manager Ruben Amorim, particularly the defeats against Newcastle United and Wolverhampton Wanderers, have raised concerns about the team’s trajectory compared under the Portuguese manager. Here are three reasons why Amorim’s United appear to be struggling more than Ten Hag’s:

1. Tactical Unsuitability

Amorim’s insistence on implementing a back three system has exposed a tactical mismatch with Manchester United’s current squad. The players, accustomed to a back four under Ten Hag, have struggled to adapt to the new formation, leading to defensive disorganization and ineffective transitions. This rigidity in tactical approach has hindered the team’s ability to perform cohesively, resulting in subpar performances.

2. Set-Piece Vulnerability

Under Amorim’s management, United have exhibited a pronounced weakness in defending set pieces. Conceding goals from corners and free-kicks has become a recurring issue, with opponents capitalizing on these opportunities to gain an advantage. This defensive frailty contrasts sharply with the more robust set-piece organization observed during Ten Hag’s era.

3. Squad Rotation and Depth Issues

Amorim’s frequent changes to the starting lineup and reliance on the maximum number of substitutions have highlighted concerns regarding squad depth and consistency. United have fielded different defensive line-ups in consecutive matches, indicating a lack of settled combinations and understanding among players. This constant rotation disrupts team chemistry and has contributed to inconsistent performances on the pitch.

In conclusion, while Manchester United are currently experiencing a challenging period under Ruben Amorim, this was to be expected. In his very first press conference,  he acknowledged the difficulties, stating, “We have to improve a lot. We have to win games and then to win titles.” Amorim believes that enduring short-term struggles is necessary for long-term success, emphasizing the importance of patience and gradual improvement. He remarked, “I am a little bit of a dreamer and I believe in myself. I also believe in the club, as I think we have the same idea, the same mindset, so that can help.”